Home » Dating sites rankings » Catholic dating sites

According to statistics, 46% of all Catholic adults in the United States are single, and that’s around 35 million people. Many of them are looking for love online, on top Catholic dating apps and sites—and in this guide, we’ll highlight the best of them and explain how they work.

Best Catholic Dating Sites 2024

Read Review »
4.9/5 stars (3280)
Read Review »
4.8/5 stars (3498)
Read Review »
4.6/5 stars (2599)

ChristianMingle — Best for Catholic Singles

  • Free version: Yes
  • Users in the US: 86%
  • Available on: Desktop, mobile browser, iOS & Android apps
  • Additional information: ChristianMingle Review
christianmingle site

Christian Mingle is known as one of the best Catholic dating sites. It’s also one of the most popular niche dating sites—currently, the platform gets over 1.6 monthly visits from people trying to find a perfect match. It’s a freemium website, and the costs for VIP plans start at $24.99 per month.

How it works: There’s a free and paid version of the site. Free users have unlimited access to profiles, can send winks, apply search filters, and though they can’t start a conversation, they can reply to messages sent by others. Paying members can enjoy unlimited communication on the dating site, hide profiles, and go anonymous if they’re seeking extra privacy.

Expert’s take:

The main benefit of using this site is that nearly all users here go to the Catholic church—for those who don’t, joining the community just doesn’t make much sense. It’s a great place to feel real Catholic chemistry, and most importantly, unlike mainstream dating sites, it’s not a platform where at least 30% of users are seeking one-night stands and casual relationships. If you’re serious about finding a long-term partner and starting a family, this might be the right site for you.

  • Great dating pool for Catholic singles
  • Detailed search criteria for finding a perfect match
  • Free members can still communicate with others
  • No video chat

EliteSingles — Best for Catholic Singles Seeking Educated Partners

  • Free version: Yes
  • Users in the US: 90%
  • Available on: Desktop, mobile browser, iOS & Android apps
  • Additional information: EliteSingles Review
elitesingles site

Educated singles looking for top Catholic dating apps and sites often choose EliteSingles—one of the top websites with over 1 million monthly visits, most of which are from the U.S. It’s not entirely free, but the prices aren’t high compared to other niche online dating platforms. Now, the costs of premium plans start at $14.95 per month.

How it works: The main reason why EliteSingles is considered one of the best online dating sites is that here, matchmaking is taken seriously. Every newcomer takes an extensive personality test, and all match suggestions are made based on your compatibility score. Free members here can send winks & likes and see other users’ personality test results, while premium users can contact others, see profile visitors and their full-size photos, and upgrade their profiles to get more attention on the site.

Expert’s take:

Though EliteSingles isn’t a niche faith-based dating site, it’s a platform with a large number of Catholic singles and a perfect place for singles over 50 who’d like to date their peers. More importantly, a person who’s looking for the best Catholic match won’t have to search for them by trial and error—algorithms and the advanced matchmaking system will do everything for you.

  • Top online dating site to meet educated singles
  • Daily matches for all users
  • Deep personality test
  • No option of finding matches manually—you can only rely on the algorithm

SilverSingles — Best for Catholic Singles Over 50

  • Free version: Yes
  • Users in the US: 96%
  • Available on: Desktop, mobile browser, iOS & Android apps
  • Additional information: SilverSingles Review
silversingles site

SilverSingles is another popular website with over 1.3 million monthly visits. There’s a free version of the site, but those who want to use special features and actually communicate with other users can buy monthly premium plans. The costs start at $13.95 per month.

How it works: Both mature women and men can join this online dating platform for free and take a detailed personality test. Free members will be able to browse profiles and use the Have You Met? feature, but photos will be blurred, and messaging will be locked. Premium users, however, can start unlimited conversations, boost their profiles, and see all the photos shared by members of the SilverSingles community.

Expert’s take:

SilverSingles, which was initially designed as a site where mature singles meet, is now known and widely used as one of the best Catholic dating apps, too. Still, belonging to the age group of 45+ is still the main characteristic of the community. Here, you can just indicate that faith is important to you when answering the questions or right in your profile, and the algorithms will suggest Catholic singles who have similar views of life.

  • Reasonable prices
  • High-quality personality test
  • Convenient online messenger
  • No free unlimited messaging

ChristianCupid — Best Cost-Effective Catholic Dating Site

  • Free version: Yes
  • Users in the US: 21%
  • Available on: Desktop, mobile browser, Android app
christiancupid site

ChristianCupid is a niche Catholic dating app and site launched by the Cupid Network. It works exclusively for people who believe the Catholic faith is important. It has over 105 thousand monthly visits. It’s a bit cheaper than other Catholic dating sites—costs start at $8.33 per month.

How it works: ChristianCupid is rightly considered one of the best places to meet Catholic singles not only because it’s designed for Catholic men and women only but also because of the great selection of features. Free users can receive messages if the sender is a Premium member, wink at others, use search, and see suggested matches. Premium users, in turn, can turn off all ads on the site, send unlimited messages, use the profile boost, use translation services, and more.

Expert’s take:

If you’re looking for Catholic dating apps where you won’t have to spend too much, ChristianCupid might be the right place for you. The platform has everything that a good Catholic dating site is supposed to have: the right dating pool, lots of free and premium features, an excellent security system, and most importantly, a transparent and reasonable pricing policy.

  • Most profiles are detailed
  • High response rate
  • Modern website with lots of special features
  • No mobile app for Apple users

Singles50 — Best for Meeting Catholic Singles Worldwide

  • Free version: Yes
  • Users in the US: 3%
  • Available on: Desktop, mobile browser, iOS, and Android apps
singles50 site

Singles50 isn’t just a Catholic community but rather a community of older singles many of whom are Catholics. It has around 2.4 million monthly visits and works for singles who want to find a perfect Catholic match not only in the US but also in other countries. Prices here start at $19.99 per month.

How it works: Singles50 uses a similar scheme as other best Catholic dating apps. Those who’ve just joined a community and haven’t upgraded their accounts yet can take a test, add as many details as they want to, share photos, and contact support. Once a user gets a premium plan, they are able to favorite other members, enjoy unlimited messaging, unlock all the photos, and more.

Expert’s take:

As the name of the site suggests, first and foremost, it’s a dating site for singles in their 50s and older. Nonetheless, it deserves to be on the list of top Catholic dating sites not only because of some great features but also because most of its members are Catholics and want to find a partner to start a serious relationship with.

  • Video call feature (app only)
  • Active community
  • Many Catholic singles
  • Most features can be used only by Premium members

How Do Catholic Dating Sites Work?

Most niche Catholic dating sites work like regular dating sites. A user creates an account, provides some information on themselves, gets access to profiles and free features, upgrades if necessary, and communicates with other members. However, there are a few things that distinguish Catholic dating apps and websites from other similar platforms:

  • They have 50%+ Catholic members
  • They are usually subscription-based but have better moderation and security systems than free websites
  • On such sites, matchmaking is taken seriously (powerful matching algorithms)
  • Most users are seeking serious commitment, not short-term relationships

If you are looking for a perfect Catholic match and want to join the best dating website, you should pay attention to a few most important criteria—the dating pool, the quality of profiles, prices, and of course, the communication features.

Who Should Use Catholic Dating Sites?

Of course, niche Catholic dating sites are designed for people for whom the Catholic faith is truly important. However, there’s another important thing that everyone who’s going to use such a website should consider. The best Catholic dating sites are websites for serious relationships—they work great for people looking for a serious commitment but are completely ineffective for those who’re seeking short-term casual relationships.

Things to Consider Before Choosing a Catholic Dating App or Site

I’d just recommend all singles remember that a Catholic dating site is still a dating site. A good platform must meet a lot of important criteria, and that’s not just about the religious beliefs of the members. There must be good communication features, detailed profiles, good moderation & security systems, and reasonable prices. Plus, there must be a minimum of fake profiles (you can’t escape them completely) and no hidden costs. Consider that, and you’ll find your Catholic match online easily and in the shortest time.

Pros and Cons of Online Catholic Dating Sites

Pros of a Catholic dating site
  • All or most members are Catholics
  • All users have the same or similar relationship goals
  • Matchmaking is taken seriously
  • Most sites sell monthly premium plans instead of credits
  • All the best communication features are available
Cons of a Catholic dating site
  • It’s usually a paid platform
  • No extra special features like video chat

Final Thoughts

Nowadays, Catholic singles, just like everyone else, can find love on a dating site. There are a lot of success stories that started online, and if you want to find your perfect Catholic match soon, too, choose the right site to narrow the search and enjoy a legitimately good online dating experience.

Sources of information:

  1. uscatholic.org
  2. similarweb.com [ChristianMingle]
Hannah O'Connor
Hanna O'Connor, an editor of Dating Tutor, has over 15 years of experience in social and relationship therapy, as well as in the international dating industry. She is the one setting the tone of future research and content, making sure that all details of each post are spot-on.
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our site uses cookies and similar tracking technologies to personalize our content and analyze our traffic.